Share to Facebook Share to Twitter Bookmark and Share
File #: Details 2017-142    Version: 1 Name:
Type: CI - Commission Initiated Investigation Status: Agenda Ready
File created: 7/27/2017 In control: PUC Agenda Meeting
On agenda: 7/27/2017 Final action:
Title: **a. E999/CI-14-643 All Electric Utilities In the Matter of the Further Investigation into Environmental and Socioeconomic Costs Under Minn. Stat. 216B.2422, Subd. 3. Whether the Federal Social Cost of Carbon is reasonable and the best available measure to determine the environmental cost of carbon dioxide (CO2) under Minn. Stat. ? 216B.2422 and, if not, what measure is better supported by the evidence. (PUC: Stalpes, DeBleeckere) **b. E999/CI-14-643 All Electric Utilities In the Matter of the Further Investigation into Environmental and Socioeconomic Costs Under Minn. Stat. 216B.2422, Subd. 3. What action should the Commission take regarding the environmental cost values for PM2.5, SO2 and NOX? (PUC: DeBleeckere, Stalpes)
Attachments: 1. 1a 01 PUC Order Establishing Environmental Cost Values 1-3-97, 2. 1a 02 Court of Appeals Opinion from 1997 Order Establishing Values 5-19-98, 3. 1a 03 PUC Order Reopening Investigation (Docket No. 00-1636) 2-10-14, 4. 1a 04 Notice of Updated Environmental Externality Values 6-16-17, 5. 1a 05 PUC Notice and Order for Hearing 10-15-14, 6. 1a 06 ALJ Order Regarding Burdens of Proof 5-17-15, 7. 1a 07 ALJ Report CO2 4-15-16, 8. 1a 08 Master Exhibit List Phase 1 CO2 11-12-15, 9. 1a 09 Issues Matrix filed by Xcel on behalf of all parties 11-12-15, 10. 1a 10 Agencies (DOC and MPCA) Initial Brief 11-24-15, 11. 1a 11 Clean Energy Business Coalition Initial Brief 11-24-15, 12. 1a 12 Clean Energy Organizations Initial Brief 11-24-15, 13. 1a 13 Doctors for a Healthy Environment Initial Brief 11-24-15, 14. 1a 14 GRE, MP, OTP Initial Brief 11-24-15, 15. 1a 15 Minnesota Large Industrial Group Initial Brief 11-24-15, 16. 1a 16 Peabody Energy Initial Brief 11-24-15, 17. 1a 17 Xcel Initial Brief 11-24-15, 18. 1a 18 Agencies (DOC and MPCA) Reply Brief 12-15-15, 19. 1a 19 Clean Energy Business Coalition Reply Brief 12-15-15, 20. 1a 20 Clean Energy Organizations Reply Brief 12-15-15, 21. 1a 21 Doctors for a Healthy Environment Reply Brief 12-15-15, 22. 1a 22 GRE, MP, OTP Reply Brief 12-15-15, 23. 1a 23 Minnesota Large Industrial Group Reply Brief 12-15-15, 24. 1a 24 Xcel Reply Brief 12-15-15, 25. 1a 25 Peabody Energy Corrected Reply Brief 12-15-15, 26. 1a 26 Agencies (DOC and MPCA) Exceptions 5-5-16, 27. 1a 27 Clean Energy Organizations Exceptions 5-5-16, 28. 1a 28 GRE, MP, OTP Exceptions 5-5-16, 29. 1a 29 Minnesota Large Industrial Group Exceptions 5-5-16, 30. 1a 30 Xcel Exceptions 5-5-16, 31. 1a 31 Agencies (DOC and MPCA) Reply Exceptions 5-16-16, 32. 1a 32 Clean Energy Organizations Reply Exceptions 5-16-16, 33. 1a 33 GRE, MP, OTP Reply Exceptions 5-16-16, 34. 1a 34 Minnesota Large Industrial Group Reply Exceptions 5-16-16, 35. 1a 35 Xcel Reply Exceptions 5-16-16, 36. 1a 36 MLIG Motion to Take Notice 7-3-17, 37. 1a 37 GRE MP OTP Response to the Motion 7-6-17, 38. 1b 01 Petition to Reopen from CEOs Memorandum 10-9-13, 39. 1b 02 Court of Appeals Opinion from 1997 Order Establishing Values 5-19-98, 40. 1b 03 PUC Order Establishing Environmental Cost Values 1-3-97, 41. 1b 04 PUC Order Reopening Investigation (Docket No. 00-1636) 2-10-14, 42. 1b 05 PUC Notice and Order for Hearing 10-15-14, 43. 1b 06 Issues Matrix filed by Xcel Energy on behalf of all parties 3-1-16, 44. 1b 07 Xcel Initial Brief 3-15-16, 45. 1b 08 Clean Energy Organizations Initial Brief 3-15-16, 46. 1b 09 Agencies (DOC and MPCA) Initial Brief 3-15-16, 47. 1b 10 Minnesota Large Industrial Group Initial Brief 3-15-16, 48. 1b 11 OTP Initial Brief 3-15-16, 49. 1b 12 Xcel Reply Brief 4-15-16, 50. 1b 13 Clean Energy Organizations Reply Brief 4-15-16, 51. 1b 14 Agencies (DOC and MPCA) Reply Brief 4-15-16, 52. 1b 15 Minnesota Large Industrial Group Reply Brief 4-15-16, 53. 1b 16 ALJ Order Regarding Burdens of Proof 3-27-15, 54. 1b 17 ALJ Report Criteria Pollutants 6-15-16, 55. 1b 18 Xcel Energy Exceptions 7-15-16, 56. 1b 19 Clean Energy Organizations Exceptions 7-15-16, 57. 1b 20 Agencies (DOC and MPCA) Exceptions 7-15-16, 58. 1b 21 Minnesota Large Industrial Group Exceptions 7-15-16, 59. 1b 22 Xcel Energy Reply Exceptions 8-4-16, 60. 1b 23 Clean Energy Organizations Reply Exceptions 8-4-16, 61. 1b 24 Agencies (DOC and MPCA) Reply Exceptions 8-4-16, 62. 1b 25 Minnesota Large Industrial Group Reply Exceptions 8-4-16, 63. 1b 26 Notice of Updated Environmental Externality Values 6-16-17, 64. Briefing Papers - CO2, 65. Briefing Papers - CP, 66. CP Phase II - Revised Decision Options

title

**a.                     E999/CI-14-643                     All Electric Utilities

In the Matter of the Further Investigation into Environmental and Socioeconomic Costs Under Minn. Stat. 216B.2422, Subd. 3.

 

Whether the Federal Social Cost of Carbon is reasonable and the best available measure to determine the environmental cost of carbon dioxide (CO2) under Minn. Stat. § 216B.2422 and, if not, what measure is better supported by the evidence. (PUC: Stalpes, DeBleeckere)

 

**b.                     E999/CI-14-643                     All Electric Utilities

In the Matter of the Further Investigation into Environmental and Socioeconomic Costs Under Minn. Stat. 216B.2422, Subd. 3.

 

What action should the Commission take regarding the environmental cost values for PM2.5, SO2 and NOX? (PUC: DeBleeckere, Stalpes)